Casey Key Real Estate

Located a few minutes south of Sarasota is the gorgeous 8-mile long barrier island of Casey Key. The Casey Key real estate market is known for having some of the most beautiful waterfront homes in Sarasota. In fact, you'll often see people passing through the island to catch a glimpse of Casey Key's large waterfront estates–many of which extend from the Gulf to the bay. The Casey Key real estate market is one of the few places where homeowners can enjoy the beach and the bay within a few steps of each other.

View MLS listings below or read more about Casey Key real estate.

Casey Key FL Real Estate Listings

priced $1,500,000 - $1,750,000

8 Search Results Found. Showing Results 1 - 5. New Search

This Newly Updated 2 Bedroom, 2 Bath Beach Retreat Is Situated On…

$1,695,000
2 Beds, 2 Baths, 1070 sqft.
Nokomis, Florida. Subdivision: Casey Key

MLS# A383719, Built in 1956

Listing information courtesy of Michael Saunders & Company.

View Property Details Save to Favorites Map this Location

Auction Feb 5th At 3pm, On-site Registration Starts At 2pm... This 1930's…

$1,600,000
5 Beds, 3 Baths, 2534 sqft.
Nokomis, Florida. Subdivision: Enchanted Isles

MLS# N5763842, Built in 1961

Listing information courtesy of Neal Vanderee & Assoc.

View Property Details Save to Favorites Map this Location

Gulf Front Home On Casey Key You Can Own This Exceptional Beach…

$1,599,000
2 Beds, 1 Baths, 892 sqft.
Nokomis, Florida. Subdivision: Casey Key

MLS# A374093, Built in 1947

Listing information courtesy of Re/max Alliance Group.

View Property Details Save to Favorites Map this Location

Casey Key Bayfront Home. Stunning Water Views Will Capture Your Attention While…

$1,595,000
3 Beds, 3 Baths, 2231 sqft.
Nokomis, Florida. Subdivision: Casey Key

MLS# A371836, Built in 1978

Listing information courtesy of Signature Sothebys Internat'l.

View Property Details Save to Favorites Map this Location

This Is A Very Inviting Custom-built Key West-style Home Built In 2002…

$1,595,000
3 Beds, 2 Baths, 3106 sqft.
Nokomis, Florida. Subdivision: Casey Key Estates

MLS# A331216, Built in 2002

Listing information courtesy of Michael Saunders & Company.

View Property Details Save to Favorites Map this Location

Casey Key Homes

Most Casey Key homes for sale bay or beach front, but there are also non-waterfront properties available as well. The architecture you'll find in Casey Key includes modern, Key West, Old Florida and Spanish-Mediterranean style homes.

Unlike a lot of areas along the Florida Coast, the Casey Key real estate market consists mostly of single family homes. There are just over 500 residences on the island, in addition to some older mom-and-pop beach front motels and low density condos that have been grandfathered under old building codes. Casey Key is unique from many parts of Florida, as the island currently does not allow large high rise condo developments in the area.

Casey Key meets Siesta Key to the north, and extends to Venice in the south. The island is easily accessible by two bridges, including a charming old-time swing bridge at the north end.

Recreation on the island is easy to find in Casey Key. Residents and visitors enjoy boating, swimming, fishing, snorkeling, playing volleyball, and strolling along the powdery white sand beaches of Casey Key. There is also a 22-acre beach park on the south end of the island that hosts a popular drum circle. Locals gather on the beach, form a circle and play a variety of musical instruments. To search for houses in Casey Key, please follow the links below.

Contact us for more information about properties for sale in Casey Key.

Homes for Sale in Casey Key, Florida

Casey Key Waterfront Homes

Waterfront homes on Casey Key include beach front, bay front, and bayou properties. Many of Casey Key's waterfront homes even extend from the Gulf to Blackburn Bay, allowing homeowners to enjoy the best of the beach and the bay.

Casey Key waterfront homes for sale

Casey Key Realtor 

Looking to buy a home or condo on Casey Key? A real estate purchase will most likely be one of your largest investments ever. Don't hire just anyone. Hire the services of a Casey Key Realtor who works hard, has vast market knowledge and years of valuable experience.

Casey Key Real Estate News

Can't find what you're looking for? Let me do the work for you. Fill out the form below and a detailed description of the type of property you're interested in, and I'll send you everything currently available.

(Fields marked with * are required.)

Top of Page