Bay Island on Siesta Key, Florida

Bay Island Siesta Key

Siesta Key, a beautiful 8-mile long barrier island visited by tourists from all across the globe and home to some 24,000 residents, was founded in 1846. Today, Siesta Key is regarded as a tropical paradise, attracting guests for its fine white sand reputed to be one of the finest and whitest in the world. The average annual temperature in the Siesta Key is 75 degrees, providing a good winter vacation getaway for some families. Commercial complexes and modern facitilites provide endless entertainment, shopping, and dining for visitors as well as residents.

Most of the residential options in the Siesta Key are condominiums. There are approximately 6,500 of them scattered across the island. Single family homes are not common in the area and have odd floor plans ranging from 800 square feet of old bungalows to greater than 8,000 square feet of some stunning waterfront homes.

One of the largest real estate developments in the Siesta Key is in Bay Island. It is an island community completely surrounded by water, affording beautiful waterfront home options for potential real estate investors. Houses located in the northern shore of Bay Island enjoy the most stunning views of the Sarasota Bay as well as the city skyline. On top of these amazing backdrops, residents of Siesta Key Bay Island have the Ringling Bridge to admire, which stretches from downtown Sarasota to Florida's Bird Key.

Siesta Key Bay Island offers residences along Flamingo Avenue, Hiegel Avenue, Hamilton Avenue, Seagrape Drive, Anglin Drive, and Freeling Drive. Homes in this charming community are some of the best in the Sarasota Florida area, offering a landscape embellished with colorful exotic plants and tropical trees.

Give us a call at 941.812.6272 if we can help you buy or sell a home on Bay Island. Visit our Siesta Key real estate page to view other great places to live in Sarasota, Florida. If Bay Island fits your budget and requirements then you should also explore Bayou Louise, Cocoanut Bayou, Gulfmead Estates, Roberts Point, Siesta Bayside and Siesta Isles.

Bay Island Sarasota

Bay Island is made up of 169 single family homes. Most of the bay front homes sell in the multi-millions. There have been sales in excess of $5 million. Non waterfront homes start in the $300,000's. Take a look at the homes for sale below.

Bay Island Houses For Sale - Updated Daily!

11 Properties Found. Showing Page 1 of 1
View As: Thumbnails List Map
Sort by:

Discover The Finest Boating Estate In Sarasota And...

$12,500,000
7 br, 9 ba, 7,194 ft² Residential
Price:
$12,500,000
City:
Sarasota
Beds:
7
Baths:
9
Type:
Residential
MLS® #:
A3954389
Provider:
Michael Saunders & Company

Discover The Finest Boating Estate In Sarasota And Possibly, The Entire West Coast Of Florida. This...

Photo of Listing #A3954389

Contemporary Splendor Inspired By The Sea. As You...

$4,100,000
6 br, 8 ba, 5,646 ft² Residential
Price:
$4,100,000
City:
Sarasota
Beds:
6
Baths:
8
Type:
Residential
MLS® #:
A3943805
Provider:
Coldwell Banker Res R E

Contemporary Splendor Inspired By The Sea. As You Enter The Gates Of This Private, Bayfront Estate,...

Photo of Listing #A3943805

Landmark Gated Bayfront Estate With Spectacular City...

$3,799,000
4 br, 5 ba, 7,045 ft² Residential
Price:
$3,799,000
City:
Sarasota
Beds:
4
Baths:
5
Type:
Residential
MLS® #:
A3936671
Provider:
Michael Saunders & Company

Landmark Gated Bayfront Estate With Spectacular City Skyline Views On One Of Sarasota's Most Prestigious...

Photo of Listing #A3936671

Rarely On The Market - One Acre On The South Side Of...

$3,650,000
4 br, 4 ba, 4,585 ft² Residential
Price:
$3,650,000
City:
Sarasota
Beds:
4
Baths:
4
Type:
Residential
MLS® #:
A3954666
Provider:
Re/max Alliance Group

Rarely On The Market - One Acre On The South Side Of Freeling Drive. Close To The North Bridge. Stunning...

Photo of Listing #A3954666

21,111 Sq Ft On One Of The Top Streets On Siesta Key....

Price:
$3,650,000
City:
Sarasota
Type:
Land
MLS® #:
A3954624
Provider:
Re/max Alliance Group

21,111 Sq Ft On One Of The Top Streets On Siesta Key. 10 Ft On The Intercoastal And Shared Fishing Pier....

Photo of Listing #A3954624

Indulge Yourself In True Florida Living With This Custom...

$2,399,000
4 br, 6 ba, 4,693 ft² Residential
Price:
$2,399,000
City:
Sarasota
Beds:
4
Baths:
6
Type:
Residential
MLS® #:
A3947765
Provider:
Michael Saunders & Company

Indulge Yourself In True Florida Living With This Custom Built Masterpiece With Spectacular, Unsurpassed...

Photo of Listing #A3947765

Right Home In The Right Place. Gorgeous Location And...

$2,200,000
5 br, 5 ba, 4,651 ft² Residential
Price:
$2,200,000
City:
Sarasota
Beds:
5
Baths:
5
Type:
Residential
MLS® #:
A3954328
Provider:
Signature Sothebys Internat'l

Right Home In The Right Place. Gorgeous Location And Views On Siesta Key. Completely Remodeled 3569 Sf...

Photo of Listing #A3954328

Great North Siesta Bay Island Location. Deep, Clean...

$1,090,000
2 br, 3 ba, 2,295 ft² Residential
Price:
$1,090,000
City:
Sarasota
Beds:
2
Baths:
3
Type:
Residential
MLS® #:
A3951864
Provider:
Era Waterside Realty

Great North Siesta Bay Island Location. Deep, Clean Water With Quick Access To Big Pass. Yacht Basin...

Photo of Listing #A3951864

Priced Below Assessed Value. Almost A Full Acre (.9819)...

$975,000
3 br, 4 ba, 2,091 ft² Residential
Price:
$975,000
City:
Sarasota
Beds:
3
Baths:
4
Type:
Residential
MLS® #:
A3929704
Provider:
Coldwell Banker Res R E

Priced Below Assessed Value. Almost A Full Acre (.9819) On Hanson Bayou. Nothing Comparable On N. Siesta...

Photo of Listing #A3929704

Priced Below Assessed Value. Almost A Full Acre (.9819)...

Price:
$975,000
City:
Sarasota
Type:
Land
MLS® #:
A3929705
Provider:
Coldwell Banker Res R E

Priced Below Assessed Value. Almost A Full Acre (.9819) On Hanson Bayou. Nothing Comparable On N. Siesta...

Photo of Listing #A3929705

Build Your Dream Home On This Wonderful Parcel On One...

Price:
$499,000
City:
Sarasota
Type:
Land
MLS® #:
A377042
Provider:
Michael Saunders & Company

Build Your Dream Home On This Wonderful Parcel On One Of The Finest Streets On Siesta Key. Live Or Rent...

Photo of Listing #A377042

* Indicates a Required Field.

Your Contact Information
Property Information
Moving Details